The Rivals of Sherlock Holmes Hugh Greene/Thames TV

Welcome to an Enjoyable Journey!!

Quite by accident I caught the first episode of the 1971 -1973 two series Thames TV production on "Talking Pictures TV".

Although a Holmes fan, I had very little idea of the many other detective authors and their detectives in the late 19th and early 20th Century.

Sir Hugh Greene, director of the BBC and brother of author Graham Green, edited the book which inspired the series. I immediately purchased a second hand copy of 

The Rivals of Sherlock Holmes: Early Detective Stories by Hugh Greene (Editor) 1971

I am thoroughly enjoying the read and the exploration of the different authors. So I have gathered some of the notes and pictures, with their links, to have them all in the same place.

I hope you enjoy them.

Thames TV Series "The Rivals of Sherlock Holmes" Episode Guide

Sir Hugh Greene (15 November 1910 – 19 February 1987) editor who inspired the series

There were two series (13 fifty-minute episodes each series) The first aired in 1971, the second in 1973. Hugh Greene was Creative Consultant on the series

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rivals_of_Sherlock_Holmes_(TV_series)  

 

Episode list  Series 1 (20 Sep - 9 Dec 1971)

 

No.

Title

Fictional Detective(s)

Author(s) of Original Story

Actor(s) who portrayed detective(s)

1x1

A Message from the Deep Sea

Dr. John Thorndyke, forensic scientist

R. Austin Freeman (1of3)

John Neville

1x2

The Missing Witness Sensation

Max Carrados, blind detective

Ernest Bramah (1of1)

Robert Stephens

1x3

The Affair of the Avalanche Bicycle & Tyre Co. Ltd.

Horace Dorrington, corrupt detective

Arthur Morrison (1of5)

Peter Vaughan

1x4

The Duchess of Wiltshire's Diamonds

Simon Carne, gentleman thief

Guy Boothby (1of1)

Roy Dotrice

1x5

The Horse of the Invisible

Thomas Carnacki, occult detective

William Hope Hodgson (1of1)

Donald Pleasence

1x6

The Case of the Mirror of Portugal

Horace Dorrington, corrupt detective

Arthur Morrison (2of5)

Peter Vaughan

1x7

Madame Sara

Dixon Druce, trade investigator

L. T. Meade (1of1) and Robert Eustace (1of1)

John Fraser

1x8

The Case of the Dixon Torpedo

Jonathan Pryde,[n 1]enquiry agent

Arthur Morrison (3of5)

Ronald Hines

1x9

The Woman in the Big Hat

Lady Molly of Scotland Yard

Emma Orczy (1of2)

Elvi Hale

1x10

The Affair of the Tortoise

Martin Hewitt, working-class detective

Arthur Morrison (4of5)

Peter Barkworth

1x11

The Assyrian Rejuvenator

Romney Pringle, reformed con artist

"Clifford Ashdown" (R. Austin Freeman (2of3) and John Pitcairn (1of1)

Donald Sinden

1x12

The Ripening Rubies

Bernard Sutton, professional jeweller

Max Pemberton (1of1)

Robert Lang

1x13

The Case of Laker, Absconded

Martin Hewitt and Jonathan Pryde[n 1]

Arthur Morrison (5of5)

Peter Barkworthand Ronald Hines

 

 

Series 2 (29 Jan - 7 May 1973)

 

No.

Title

Fictional Detective(s)

Author(s) of Original Story

Actor(s) who portrayed detective(s)

2x1

The Mysterious Death on the Underground Railway

Polly Burton,[n 2] lady journalist

Emma Orczy (2of2)

Judy Geeson

2x2

Five Hundred Carats

Inspector Lipinzki, South African police detective

George Griffith (1of1)

Barry Keegan

2x3

Cell 13

Prof Van Dusen, the Thinking Machine

Jacques Futrelle (1of2)

Douglas Wilmer

2x4

The Secret of the Magnifique

John Laxworthy, reformed criminal

E. Phillips Oppenheim (1of1)

Bernard Hepton

2x5

The Absent-Minded Coterie

Eugene Valmont, private investigator

Robert Barr (1of1)

Charles Gray

2x6

The Sensible Action of Lieutenant Holst

Lieutenant Holst, Danish police detective

Palle Rosenkrantz (1of1)

John Thaw

2x7

The Superfluous Finger

Prof Van Dusen, the Thinking Machine

Jacques Futrelle (2of2)

Douglas Wilmer

2x8

Anonymous Letters

Dagobert Trostler, Viennese sleuth

"Balduin Groller" (Adalbert Goldscheider) (1of1)

Ronald Lewis

2x9

The Moabite Cypher

Dr. John Thorndyke, forensic scientist

R. Austin Freeman (3of3)

Barrie Ingham

2x10

The Secret of the Fox Hunter

Duckworth Drew of the Secret Service

William Le Queux (1of1)

Derek Jacobi

2x11

The Looting of the Specie Room

Mr. Horrocks, ship's purser

C. J. Cutcliffe Hyne (1of1)

Ronald Fraser

2x12

The Mystery of the Amber Beads

Hagar Stanley, Gypsy detective

Fergus Hume (1of1)

Sara Kestelman

2x13

The Missing Q.C.s

Charles Dallas, defense barrister

"John Oxenham" (William Arthur Dunkerley) (1of1)

Robin Ellis

 

Stories in the TV Series by Author

Edition of the book published with the TV series

By Author

AUTHOR

TV no

Title

Detective

Author number

Actor

R. Austin Freeman

1x1

A Message from the Deep Sea

Dr. John Thorndyke, forensic scientist

R. Austin Freeman (1of3)

John Neville

R. Austin Freeman

(aka Clifford Ashdown)

 

John Pitcairn

1x11

The Assyrian Rejuvenator

Romney Pringle, reformed con artist

"Clifford Ashdown" (R. Austin Freeman (2of3) and John Pitcairn (1of1)

Donald Sinden

 

2x9

The Moabite Cypher

Dr. John Thorndyke, forensic scientist

R. Austin Freeman (3of3)

Barrie Ingham

Ernest Bramah

1x2

The Missing Witness Sensation

Max Carrados, blind detective

Ernest Bramah (1of1)

Robert Stephens

Arthur Morrison

1x3

The Affair of the Avalanche Bicycle & Tyre Co. Ltd.

Horace Dorrington, corrupt detective

Arthur Morrison (1of5)

Peter Vaughan

 

1x6

The Case of the Mirror of Portugal

Horace Dorrington, corrupt detective

Arthur Morrison (2of5)

Peter Vaughan

 

1x8

The Case of the Dixon Torpedo

Jonathan Pryde,[n 1]enquiry agent

Arthur Morrison (3of5)

Ronald Hines

 

1x10

The Affair of the Tortoise

Martin Hewitt, working-class detective

Arthur Morrison (4of5)

Peter Barkworth

 

1x13

The Case of Laker, Absconded

Martin Hewitt and Jonathan Pryde[n 1]

Arthur Morrison (5of5)

Peter Barkworthand Ronald Hines

Guy Boothby

1x4

The Duchess of Wiltshire's Diamonds

Simon Carne, gentleman thief

Guy Boothby (1of1)

Roy Dotrice

William Hope Hodgson

1x5

The Horse of the Invisible

Thomas Carnacki, occult detective

William Hope Hodgson (1of1)

Donald Pleasence

L. T. Meade

 

Robert Eustace

1x7

Madame Sara

Dixon Druce, trade investigator

L. T. Meade (1of1) and Robert Eustace (1of1)

John Fraser

Emma Orczy

1x9

The Woman in the Big Hat

Lady Molly of Scotland Yard

Emma Orczy (1of2)

Elvi Hale

 

2x1

The Mysterious Death on the Underground Railway

Polly Burton,[n 2] lady journalist

Emma Orczy (2of2)

Judy Geeson

 

 

 

 

AUTHOR

TV no

Title

Detective

Author number

Actor

Max Pemberton

1x12

The Ripening Rubies

Bernard Sutton, professional jeweller

Max Pemberton (1of1)

Robert Lang

George Griffith

2x2

Five Hundred Carats

Inspector Lipinzki, South African police detective

George Griffith (1of1)

Barry Keegan

Jacques Futrelle

2x3

Cell 13

Prof Van Dusen, the Thinking Machine

Jacques Futrelle (1of2)

Douglas Wilmer

 

2x7

The Superfluous Finger

Prof Van Dusen, the Thinking Machine

Jacques Futrelle (2of2)

Douglas Wilmer

E. Phillips Oppenheim

2x4

The Secret of the Magnifique

John Laxworthy, reformed criminal

E. Phillips Oppenheim (1of1)

Bernard Hepton

Robert Barr

2x5

The Absent-Minded Coterie

Eugene Valmont, private investigator

Robert Barr (1of1)

Charles Gray

Palle Rosenkrantz

2x6

The Sensible Action of Lieutenant Holst

Lieutenant Holst, Danish police detective

Palle Rosenkrantz (1of1)

John Thaw

Adalbert Goldscheider

(akaBalduin Groller)

2x8

Anonymous Letters

Dagobert Trostler, Viennese sleuth

"Balduin Groller" (Adalbert Goldscheider) (1of1)

Ronald Lewis

William Le Queux

2x10

The Secret of the Fox Hunter

Duckworth Drew of the Secret Service

William Le Queux (1of1)

Derek Jacobi

C. J. Cutcliffe Hyne

2x11

The Looting of the Specie Room

Mr. Horrocks, ship's purser

C. J. Cutcliffe Hyne (1of1)

Ronald Fraser

Fergus Hume

2x12

The Mystery of the Amber Beads

Hagar Stanley, Gypsy detective

Fergus Hume (1of1)

Sara Kestelman

William Arthur Dunkerley

(aka "John Oxenham)

2x13

The Missing Q.C.s

Charles Dallas, defense barrister

"John Oxenham" (William Arthur Dunkerley) (1of1)

Robin Ellis

Biographies 1. Robert Barr (16 September 1849 –21 October 1912)

 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Barr_(writer)

 

Robert Barr (16 September 1849 – 21 October 1912) was a Scottish-Canadian short story writer and novelist.

 

2, Guy Newell Boothby (13 October 1867– 26 February 1905)

2. Guy Boothbyhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guy_Boothby

 

Guy Newell Boothby (13 October 1867 – 26 February 1905) was a prolific Australian novelist and writer, noted for sensational fiction in variety magazines around the end of the nineteenth century. He lived mainly in England. He is best known for such works as the Dr Nikola series, about an occultist criminal mastermind who is a Victorian forerunner to Fu Manchu, and Pharos, the Egyptian, a tale of Gothic Egypt, mummies' curses and supernatural revenge. Rudyard Kiplingwas his friend and mentor, and his books were remembered with affection by George Orwell.[1]

3. Ernest Bramah (20 March 1868[1] – 27 June 1942)

3. Ernest Bramah  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ernest_Bramah

 

Ernest Bramah (20 March 1868[1] – 27 June 1942), whose name was recorded after his birth as Ernest Brammah Smith, was an English author.[2] He published 21 books and numerous short stories and features. His humorous works were ranked with Jerome K. Jerome and W. W. Jacobs, his detective stories with Conan Doyle, his politico-science fiction with H. G. Wells and his supernatural stories with Algernon BlackwoodGeorge Orwellacknowledged that Bramah's book, What Might Have Been, influenced his Nineteen Eighty-Four. Bramah created the characters Kai Lung and Max Carrados.

4. William Arthur Dunkerley (12 November 1852 – 23 January 1941)

4. William Arthur Dunkerley (aka John Oxenham) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Arthur_Dunkerley

 

William Arthur Dunkerley (12 November 1852 – 23 January 1941) was an English journalistnovelist and poet. He was born in Manchester, spent a short time after his marriage in the US before moving to Ealing, West London, where he served as deacon and teacher at the Ealing Congregational Church from the 1880s. In 1922 he moved to Worthing in Sussex, where he became the town's mayor.

5. Robert Eustace (1854–1943)

5. Robert Eustace  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Eustace

 

Robert Eustace was the pen name of Eustace Robert Barton (1854–1943), an English doctor and author of mystery and crime fiction with a theme of scientific innovation. He also wrote as Eustace Robert Rawlings. Eustace often collaborated with other writers, producing a number of works with the author L. T. Meade and others. He is credited as co-author with Dorothy L. Sayers of the novel The Documents in the Case, for which he supplied the main plot idea and supporting medical and scientific details.

6. Richard Austin Freeman (11 April 1862 – 28 September 1943)

6. R. Austin Freeman (aka Clifford Ashdown) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R._Austin_Freeman

 

Richard Austin Freeman (11 April 1862 – 28 September 1943) was a British writer of detective stories, mostly featuring the medico-legal forensic investigator Dr. Thorndyke. He claimed to have invented the inverted detective story (a crime fiction in which the commission of the crime is described at the beginning, usually including the identity of the perpetrator, with the story then describing the detective's attempt to solve the mystery). Freeman used some of his early experiences as a colonial surgeon in his novels.

Many of the Dr. Thorndyke stories involve genuine, but often quite arcane, points of scientific knowledge, from areas such as tropical medicinemetallurgy and toxicology.

 

7. Jacques Heath Futrelle (April 9, 1875 – April 15, 1912)

7. Jacques Futrellehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacques_Futrelle

 

Jacques Heath Futrelle (April 9, 1875 – April 15, 1912) was an American journalist and mystery writer. He is best known for writing short detective stories featuring Professor Augustus S. F. X. Van Dusen, also known as "The Thinking Machine" for his application of logic to any and all situations. Futrelle died in the sinking of the RMS Titanic. 

8. Adalbert Goldscheider, (5 September 1848 – 22 March 1916)

8. Adalbert Goldscheider (aka Balduin Groller)  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balduin_Groller

 

Adalbert Goldscheider, (5 September 1848 – 22 March 1916) better known by his pseudonym Balduin Groller, was an Austrian journalist and author as well as the founder of the Austrian Olympic Committee.

9. George Griffith (1857–1906)

9. George Griffith  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Griffith

 

George Griffith (1857–1906), full name George Chetwynd Griffith-Jones, was a prolific British science fiction writer and noted explorer who wrote during the late Victorian and Edwardian age. Many of his visionary tales appeared in magazines such as Pearson's Magazine and Pearson's Weekly before being published as novels. Griffith was extremely popular in the United Kingdom, though he failed to find similar acclaim in the United States, in part due to his utopian socialist views. A journalist, rather than scientist, by background, what his stories lack in scientific rigour and literary grace they make up for in sheer exuberance of execution.

10. William Hope Hodgson (15 November 1877 – 19 April 1918)

10. William Hope Hodgsonhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Hope_Hodgson

 

William Hope Hodgson (15 November 1877 – 19 April 1918) was an English author. He produced a large body of work, consisting of essays, short fiction, and novels, spanning several overlapping genres including horrorfantastic fiction, and science fiction.

11. Fergus Hume (8 July 1859 – 12 July 1932)

11. Fergus Hume  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fergus_Hume

 

Fergusson Wright Hume (8 July 1859 – 12 July 1932), known as Fergus Hume, was a prolific English novelist.

12. Charles John Cutcliffe Wright Hyne (11 May 1866–10 March 1944)

12. C. J. Cutcliffe Hyne  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C._J._Cutcliffe_Hyne

 

Charles John Cutcliffe Wright Hyne (11 May 1866 – 10 March 1944) was an English[1] novelist who was also known by the pen name Weatherby Chesney. He is perhaps best remembered as the author of The Lost Continent: The Story of Atlantis. He is also remembered for his Captain Kettle stories and for The Recipe for Diamonds.

13. William Tufnell Le Queux (2 July 1864 - 13 October 1927)

13. William Le Queux  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Le_Queux

 

William Tufnell Le Queux (2 July 1864 - 13 October 1927) was an Anglo-French journalist and writer. He was also a diplomat (honorary consul for San Marino), a traveller (in Europe, the Balkans and North Africa), a flying buff who officiated at the first British air meeting at Doncaster in 1909, and a wireless pioneer who broadcast music from his own station long before radio was generally available; his claims regarding his own abilities and exploits, however, were usually exaggerated. His best-known works are the anti-French and anti-Russian invasion fantasy The Great War in England in 1897 (1894) and the anti-German invasion fantasy The Invasion of 1910 (1906), the latter of which was a phenomenal bestseller.

14. L. T. Meade (1844–1914)

14. L. T. Meade  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L._T._Meade

 

L. T. Meade was the pseudonym of Elizabeth Thomasina Meade Smith (1844–1914), a prolific writer of girls' stories. She was born in Bandon, County Cork, Ireland, daughter of Rev. R. T. Meade, of Nohoval, County Cork.[1] She later moved to London, where she married Alfred Toulmin Smith in September 1879.

15. Arthur George Morrison (1 November 1863 – 4 December 1945)

15. Arthur Morrison  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Morrison

 

Arthur George Morrison (1 November 1863 – 4 December 1945) was an English writer and journalist known for his realistic novels and stories about working-class life in London's East End, and for his detective stories, featuring the detective Martin Hewitt. He also collected Japanese art and published several works on the subject. He left a large collection of paintings and other works of art to the British Museum after his death in 1945.[1] Morrison's best known work of fiction is his novel A Child of the Jago (1896).

16. Edward Phillips Oppenheim (22 October 1866 – 3 February 1946)

16. E. Phillips Oppenheim  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._Phillips_Oppenheim

 

Edward Phillips Oppenheim (22 October 1866 – 3 February 1946) was an English novelist, in his lifetime a major and successful writer of genre fiction including thrillers.

17. Baroness Emma Orczy (23 September 1865 – 12 November 1947)

17. Emma Orczy  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emma_Orczy

 

Baroness Emma Magdolna Rozália Mária Jozefa Borbála"EmmuskaOrczy de Orci (/ˈɔːrtsiː/; 23 September 1865 – 12 November 1947) was a Hungarian-born British novelist and playwright. She is best known for her series of novels featuring the Scarlet Pimpernel, the alter ego of Sir Percy Blakeney, a wealthy English fop who turns into a quick-thinking escape artist in order to save ill-fated French royalty from "Madame Guillotine" during the French revolution, establishing the "hero with a secret identity" into popular culture.

18. Sir Max Pemberton (19 June 1863 – 22 February 1950)

18. Max Pembertonhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Pemberton

 

Sir Max Pemberton (19 June 1863 – 22 February 1950) was a popular English novelist, working mainly in the adventure and mystery genres. [3] He was educated at St Albans SchoolMerchant Taylors' School, and Caius College, Cambridge.[4] A clubman, journalist and dandy (Lord Northcliffe admired his 'fancy vests'), he frequented both Fleet Street and The Savage Club.

19. John Pitcairn (1860-1936)

19. John Pitcairn

https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/13439286.J_J_Pitcairn

 

Dr. John James Pitcairn (1860-1936) wrote several books/stories in collaboration with R. Austin Freeman under the pseudonym Clifford Ashdown. He was Medical Officer at Holloway Prison and lived in Uckfield East Sussex.

20. Palle Rosenkrantz (1867-1941)

20. Palle Rosenkrantz

https://vintage-crime.livejournal.com/146615.html

 

Baron Palle Adam Vilhelm Rosenkrantz (1867-1941) was a successful Danish writer who wrote, among other works, detective fiction. In fact there’s a prize for crime fiction in Denmark named after him. It seems that little of his crime fiction has been translated into English although one of his Lieutenant Holst short stories was included in one of Hugh Greene’s Rivals of Sherlock Holmes anthologies (and was adapted for television in the early 1970s Rivals of Sherlock Holmes series). And his crime novel The Magistrate’s Own Case is available in an English translation.

Latest comments

17.04 | 22:49

Hi Lucy.

Good to hear from you. Send me any details. My Mentastis were from Albiolo near Varese. Use the Contact page if you want to send me your email address

17.04 | 22:36

I am doing some research, i think my Mentasti family are related to yours as my g grandfather was from lombardia, he came to work as a cook in relatives' hotel

08.08 | 19:48

http://www.british-history.ac.uk/survey-london/vols31-2/pt2/pp68-84#h3-0002 is the page about the Shaftesbury Ave. project. It has a map of the proposed street.

08.08 | 19:47

That atrium cover is not far in from Coventry St. I expected it to be closer to Shaftesbuy. Thank you!